Top 7 Tips for Managing Guest Post Submissions

Managing guest post submissions effectively can save time, improve content quality, and boost engagement for your Shopify blog. Here’s a quick summary of the 7 tips to streamline the process:

  1. Set Clear Submission Guidelines: Define content requirements, preferred topics, SEO rules, and review timelines to ensure quality upfront.
  2. Use a Centralized Tool: Simplify the workflow with tools like submission forms or platforms like Trello for tracking and organizing posts.
  3. Create a Step-by-Step Review Process: Screen for originality, SEO, and readability while providing clear feedback to contributors.
  4. Edit for Consistency: Focus on grammar, structure, and tone while aligning with your blog's style and SEO goals.
  5. Encourage Engagement: Prioritize posts with actionable tips, visuals, and interactive elements that resonate with readers.
  6. Plan and Schedule in Advance: Maintain a content calendar to ensure timely publication and diverse topics.
  7. Track Performance and Feedback: Use metrics like traffic, engagement, and SEO to refine your strategy and improve future submissions.

Blog Content Strategy: How To Structure Your Entire Blog

1. Set Clear Submission Guidelines

Having clear submission guidelines helps maintain quality and attracts contributors who share your blog's vision. It also builds a stronger sense of community. Here's what you should include in your guidelines:

Key Elements

  • Content Requirements
    Ensure submissions are original, engaging, and well-researched. Include visuals or screenshots where relevant, and aim for a conversational tone that connects with readers. Specify minimum word counts.
  • Topics to Cover
    Focus on areas like:
    • Shopify store optimization [2]
    • E-commerce strategies
    • Digital marketing tips
    • Customer engagement techniques
  • Submission Format
    Ask for meta information (title, description, and internal links) and high-resolution images with proper attribution.

Technical Details

Provide SEO instructions, such as target keywords, header structure, meta tags, and alt text for images. This ensures submissions are optimized for search engines.

Review Process

Clarify the review timeline, revision expectations, publication schedule, and ownership rights upfront. Transparency here avoids confusion later.

Once your guidelines are ready, focus on organizing and simplifying the submission process.

2. Use a Centralized Tool for Submissions

Handling guest post submissions through scattered emails or various platforms can quickly get messy. A centralized tool can simplify the process, keep things organized, and maintain consistent quality.

Key Features to Consider

When picking a submission tool, look for these features:

  • Automated notifications to track submissions and updates
  • Content sorting by topic and status for easy management
  • Team collaboration options for smoother workflows
  • Integration capabilities with tools you already use
  • Support for media files, like images and attachments

How to Put This Into Practice

If you run a Shopify store, adding a submission form to your contact page can help standardize entries. Since Shopify doesn’t support multiple contributors, this approach creates a structured and user-friendly system for contributors, boosting participation and reliability [3].

For smaller blogs, tools like Trello can help you manage submissions efficiently. If simplicity is your priority, a basic contact form might be enough. Larger blogs with higher submission volumes may benefit from CMS platforms with built-in advanced features.

Making Your Workflow Smoother

Automated tools can improve efficiency at three critical stages:

  • Submission Receipt: Automatically send acknowledgments and categorize new entries.
  • Review and Edit: Check for compliance with your guidelines and handle revisions.
  • Schedule and Publish: Sync with your content calendar to ensure timely posting.

Once you’ve organized submissions, the next step is setting up a clear review process to maintain quality and consistency.

3. Create a Step-by-Step Review Process

A clear review process is key to maintaining high-quality guest posts without wasting time. It ensures consistency across all submissions and builds trust with contributors.

Initial Assessment and Review

Begin with a quick check to evaluate originality, relevance, formatting, and word count. If the post meets basic requirements, move on to a more detailed review using this framework:

Review Stage Key Actions Quality Indicators
Content and Engagement Assess research quality, accuracy, and value for readers Credible sources, practical takeaways
Technical Review Review SEO elements and formatting Correct keyword placement, clear headings
Readability Check structure and flow Easy-to-read paragraphs, smooth transitions

Streamlined Editing Process

Leverage tools like Google Docs to provide real-time feedback, manage versions, and communicate clearly with contributors [1]. This collaborative method keeps the editing process efficient and transparent.

Quality Control

Before publishing, double-check technical details, brand alignment, SEO optimization, and image quality. Offer clear, constructive feedback to help contributors refine their work.

Timeline Management

Establish specific timeframes for each stage. For example, allow 24-48 hours for the initial screening and 3-5 days for detailed reviews. This keeps the process efficient while ensuring thorough evaluations.

Once your review process is set, you’ll be ready to ensure every post aligns with your blog's standards and expectations.

sbb-itb-59b615f

4. Edit Submissions for Quality and Consistency

Once you’ve set up a solid review process, the next step is editing submissions to ensure high-quality content while keeping each writer’s unique perspective intact. Thoughtful editing not only improves the content but also makes the workflow smoother, saving time and keeping your blog consistent.

Focus Areas for Quality Editing

When reviewing guest submissions, pay attention to these key areas to maintain quality and uniformity:

Editing Focus Key Elements Tools/Resources
Technical Accuracy Grammar, spelling, formatting Grammar checkers, style guides
Content Structure Flow, readability, transitions Content management systems
SEO Elements Keywords, meta tags, headings Yoast SEO, SurferSEO

Aligning Style, Tone, and Standards

Make sure every post aligns with your blog’s style and tone by establishing clear editorial guidelines. Define whether the tone should be conversational or professional, and set measurable SEO goals like keyword difficulty and search volume.

To enhance content, focus on:

  • Adding SEO components like meta titles, descriptions, and structured headings
  • Breaking content into easy-to-read sections
  • Using visuals with proper alt text
  • Incorporating relevant internal links

Strengthening Contributor Relationships

Editing isn’t just about fixing mistakes - it’s an opportunity to build stronger connections with your contributors. Provide actionable feedback that explains why changes were made. This not only improves their future submissions but also fosters long-term partnerships.

Final Quality Checklist

Before wrapping up edits, confirm these essential points:

  • Value: Does the content provide useful advice or insights?
  • Brand Alignment: Is the tone and messaging consistent with your blog?
  • Technical Details: Are formatting and SEO guidelines followed?
  • Engagement: Does the content encourage reader interaction?

Once the edits are complete, you’ll be ready to schedule the post and keep your publishing calendar on track.

5. Focus on Posts That Encourage Engagement

Once you've polished your content through review and editing, the next step is to zero in on posts that spark meaningful interactions and deliver true value to your readers.

Key Elements of Engaging Content

Element How to Apply It
Practical Tips Offer clear, actionable steps readers can use
Visual Content Use infographics to simplify complex ideas
Reader Stories Share real-world case studies and experiences
Interactive Elements Include polls, surveys, or discussion prompts

Smart Placement of Engagement Features

Incorporate your engagement tools strategically throughout your content:

  • After introducing new ideas
  • Following detailed examples
  • During transitions between sections
  • Toward the end of the post to encourage further action

Encouraging Reader Participation

Create posts that directly address your audience's challenges. For instance, if your Shopify blog focuses on e-commerce strategies, prioritize content that tackles specific pain points, like increasing cart conversions, rather than broad industry updates.

Boosting Technical Interaction

Use tools that make it easy for readers to engage. Shopify store owners, for example, might explore tools like Better Blog Comments to organize discussions with features like threaded replies and notifications.

Tracking Engagement Success

Keep an eye on these metrics to understand how well your content is driving engagement:

Metric Category What to Measure
Reader Interaction Quality of comments and time spent on page
Reach and Loyalty Social shares and repeat visitor behavior
Community Growth Depth of discussions and variety of participants

6. Plan and Schedule Posts in Advance

Having a clear content calendar is crucial for managing guest posts while keeping quality and consistency intact. Here’s how to set up an effective scheduling system:

Calendar Essentials and Publishing Schedule

When creating your calendar, make sure it tracks these important details:

Component Purpose How to Use It
Publication Date Keeps posting consistent Space posts 2-3 weeks apart
Author Details Tracks contributors Note their expertise areas
Topic Category Ensures diverse content Rotate themes each month

For business readers, aim to publish on weekday mornings. A predictable schedule not only ensures timely publication but also builds trust with guest contributors, increasing the likelihood of future submissions.

Planning Ahead

Always have a month’s worth of guest posts approved and ready to go. This helps you:

  • Maintain quality during busy periods
  • Avoid disruptions from unexpected delays
  • Align posts with seasonal trends
  • Create cohesive content series

Tools and Tracking

While spreadsheets can work for basic planning, content platforms make it easier to track submissions and schedules. Use these tools to monitor how your publishing schedule impacts key metrics such as:

  • Timing of publications
  • Performance of content series
  • Seasonal engagement trends

Additionally, track reader engagement, contributor reliability, and popular topics. This data will help you fine-tune your schedule and focus on content that resonates most with your audience.

Once your schedule is running smoothly, you’ll be ready to dive into performance analysis and feedback to improve your process even further.

7. Track Performance and Gather Feedback

Tracking how your guest posts perform is critical for improving your content strategy and future submissions. Here’s how you can take a data-driven approach to evaluate your efforts.

Key Metrics to Track

Focus on these metrics to measure and refine your guest post strategy:

Metric Type What to Measure Why It’s Important Target Goals
Engagement Comments, likes, shares Shows how readers interact 2-3x the average post interaction
Traffic Page views, time on page Indicates how far your content reaches Bounce rate below 40%
SEO Keyword rankings, backlinks Reflects search engine visibility Top 3 rankings for target terms
Conversions Email signups, sales Connects posts to business results At least 2% conversion rate

Tools for Tracking

Leverage tools like Google Analytics and Shopify's built-in tracking features to monitor performance. For deeper insights into engagement, consider using tools like Better Blog Comments to analyze reader interactions and identify successful content themes.

Gathering Feedback

Collecting feedback is just as important as tracking metrics. Here are a few ways to gather meaningful insights:

  • Check blog comments for direct feedback and reader discussions.
  • Send email surveys to subscribers who engage with your content.
  • Monitor social media activity, including mentions, shares, and comments, to see how far your content spreads.

Using Data for Improvement

Use the data you collect to refine your approach. For example, long-form posts between 2,500 and 3,000 words tend to generate 38% more engagement [1]. Compare your performance to industry standards - Google suggests blog bounce rates should fall between 26-40% [4]. These benchmarks can guide your strategy.

Monthly Review Checklist

Set aside time each month to analyze key areas:

  • Which topics and formats performed best?
  • What engagement patterns or trends emerged?
  • How is your SEO strategy affecting keyword rankings?
  • Are guest authors contributing high-quality content?

Collaborating with Authors

Keep guest authors in the loop by sharing performance data and asking for their feedback on the submission process. This not only strengthens your working relationship but also helps them tailor future submissions to your audience’s preferences.

Conclusion

Effectively managing guest post submissions is key to creating a strong blog community for your Shopify store. Clear submission guidelines can lead to better drafts and cut revision time by 40%, while the right tools can simplify the process and improve results.

Using tools like Better Blog Comments can boost engagement by encouraging discussions and feedback. Paired with performance tracking, these tools help refine your strategy to better align with your audience's preferences.

Making decisions based on data is critical for improving your guest posting efforts. By reviewing metrics and engagement trends, as discussed earlier, store owners can make smarter choices about content direction and relationships with contributors.

To build on the engagement strategies from section 5, managing guest posts successfully depends on three main factors:

  • Maintaining quality with detailed review processes
  • Encouraging community interaction to foster strong connections
  • Analyzing performance regularly to steer content decisions

This structured approach ensures your blog stays relevant and useful to your audience while keeping guest contributions up to standard.

Back to blog

Install Better Blog Comments on your Shopify store

Elevate your Shopify blog with advanced spam protection, threaded replies, email notifications, and a 5 star rating system. Try it out with a 10 day free trial.